Reuters — Canadian Pacific Railway said on Saturday it filed a formal objection with a U.S. regulator, stating Canadian National Railway’s near US$30 billion rival bid for Kansas City Southern does not qualify to be exempted from tougher merger rules.
Last week, the U.S. Surface Transportation Board (STB) granted a waiver to CP’s $25 billion agreed bid for Kansas City Southern, which means the deal would not be subjected to the tougher railroad merger rules the regulator put in place in 2001 (all figures US$).
CP won the exemption based on its smaller size, and analysts and shareholders have said that STB’s ruling reduces the regulatory risk to CP’s deal.
CP and larger rival CN are in a race to take over U.S. railroad Kansas City Southern (KCS), which would create the first direct railway linking Canada, U.S. and Mexico.
Either combination is seeking to benefit from the expected pick-up in trade after the Canada-U.S.-Mexico Agreement was ratified last year.
In its argument filed with the regulator on Friday, CP said CN’s offer to acquire KCS should be cause for concern because of its size.
“A combined CN/KCS would greatly expand the size of the fifth largest U.S. Class 1 railroad, vastly increasing the gap between CN/KCS and… CP,” Canadian Pacific said.
CN said it has voluntarily agreed to have its transaction with KCS reviewed by the STB under the current rules to demonstrate the pro-competitive nature of the deal and to address any competition concerns.
KCS did not immediately respond to a request for comment on CP’s filing to the regulator.
CP has previously said it was not considering increasing its offer. KCS previously said its board has determined that CN’s competing offer could be expected to lead to a “superior proposal.”
— Reporting for Reuters by Shubham Kalia in Bangalore.