Your Reading List

Profit versus production in the cattle business: Part 2

calf and cow in a pasture

Last month we looked at cow size and profit. This month let’s look at calving dates and profit. I realize that this can be a controversial and emotional topic. My idea is to challenge you to figure out with your own numbers what calving dates will produce the most profit on your unique operation. There is a lot of tradition in the cow-calf business. Often we do things without a clear financial analysis. I think we will all be better off when we can put clear numbers to our various management decisions. I wish you success in figuring out the most profitable time to calve.

With the stronger cattle prices we appear to be in a new era in the cow-calf business. This would be an ideal time to evaluate all our management decisions. We have a wonderful opportunity to build more profitable and more sustainable operations.

My first suggestion to help determine calving dates is to look at the wildlife in your area. When do moose, deer, elk or antelope have their young? Most wildlife calve from mid-May to late June. I believe there is a message here. Wildlife calve in May and June for two basic reasons: first, survival of the young is highest then and, second, rebreeding of the females is higher when they calve at this time of the year.

In agriculture we have a long history of trying to dominate nature. Calving date is a classic example. There is no doubt we can dominate nature in the short term. However, it is important to remember that nature will bat last and has very deep pockets. When we try and dominate nature we increase costs and reduce profit.

  • More ‘Holistic Ranching’ with Don Campbell: Profit versus production: Part 1

If we are in business to produce a profit we will want to calve when costs are low and the survival rate of the young is high. Mimicking nature by calving in May and June is likely to lead to our desired result.

I think that most of us will agree that a cow needs her best nutrition from the day she calves until the day she is bred. Grass is the most nutritious feed we have. It is also the cheapest feed available. Calving in May and June will help us meet the nutritional requirements of our animals at the lowest-possible cost. This will lead to a high rebreeding percentage. This is important as there is a strong correlation between rebreeding and profit.

Calving earlier increases feed costs. It is also likely to increase the cost of feeding the feed. Despite our higher feed costs rebreeding rates may also suffer. Clearly these higher costs have the potential to lower profits.

Now let’s consider labour and investment costs as related to calving dates. Both will be lowest with May/June calvings. Some of you may be concerned with having your cows calve without constant checking. For a cow to have a calf is the most natural thing in the world. Our job is to provide adequate nutrition, easy-calving bulls and a natural environment for the cow. When these conditions are met we might be best advised to get out of the way and let nature take over. Perhaps the less management we provide the more profitable we will be.

Calving earlier will increase both labour and investment costs. One of the keys to having a profitable cow herd is to have a low investment per cow. Any infrastructure associated with calving will increase our investment per cow.

Marketing at a particular time or producing a certain weaning weight might be another reason to calve early. Here again we can do a financial analysis of our business. For example, if you want to market 800-pound calves is it more profitable to calve early and sell this weight of calf at weaning? How would later calving and backgrounding to reach 800 pounds compare? Which might be more profitable?

I would like to share a couple of stories. Hopefully they will challenge your thinking. The first one is some work done many years ago at one of the research stations in Western Canada. The idea was to compare calving in February and April. Two similar groups of cows were calved out. The calves were weaned and sold on the same day in Oct. The conclusion was that the February calves made more money. This conclusion was correct. What was completely overlooked was the extra cost of calving in February. There was also no mention of how the two groups rebred. This is a classic example of the production paradigm as compared to the profit paradigm. The production paradigm has been strongly encouraged by agribusiness, government and extension services. The production paradigm may serve agribusiness. It does very little for the primary producer. At our level profit is king. Production is secondary.

My second story is about a young person who has recently graduated from university. He has landed a job as a feed salesman. While travelling in his area he meets an older farmer who lives well off the beaten track. He is not very progressive by the young man’s standards. But when the young man stops to visit he sees pigs of all ages and sizes everywhere basically running free. The young man suggests to the older man, “I think I can figure out a ration that will get your pigs to market sooner.”

“Really,” replies the older man. “It’s OK by me, please figure it out.”

In two weeks the young man returns. He excitedly explains to the older man how if he will just pen his pigs and buy some feed from him his pigs will get to market two weeks sooner. The older man thinks for a moment or two and replies: “You might be right sonny. But what is time to a pig?”

I wish you success in building a profitable business. Remember, to improve we have to be willing to challenge the status quo. Happy trails.

Don Campbell ranches with his family at Meadow Lake, Sask., and teaches Holistic Management courses. He can be reached at 306-236-6088 or by email.

About the author


Don Campbell

Don Campbell ranches with his family at Meadow Lake, Sask., 
and teaches Holistic Management courses.



Stories from our other publications